AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

Private Equity and Private Debt: Two Sides of the Same Coin

Reported by Cfainstitute
Mar 31, 2025· 3 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • CFA Institute Research and Policy Center argues private equity and private debt are increasingly intertwined, with alternative managers playing on both sides of the capital structure as equity sponsors, lenders, and bondholders.
  • • Carlyle's investment in Cotiviti was backed by a syndicate including Apollo and Blackstone credit arms in a $5.5 billion loan, described as the largest private debt transaction ever as of early 2023.
  • • The article contends that dual roles give managers access to confidential information, potential conflicts of interest, and fee generation from restructurings, amendments, and director, arrangement, and consent fees.
  • • Lack of transparency in private credit, including voluntary marking and deferred interest payments, raises concerns about hidden distress and information asymmetry during a credit downturn.
  • • The top 10 private credit firms control roughly a third of sector AUM, and the top 10 private equity managers accounted for more than 22% of global funds raised last year, which the author says warrants regulatory monitoring.
Summary
Private equity (PE) and private debt (PD) are often treated as distinct strategies, but according to a CFA Institute Research and Policy Center post, the two are increasingly intertwined. The article cites the dispute between KKR and Bain Capital over Fuji Soft as an example of hostility among PE firms, while noting that the rise of private credit has driven more collaboration among them.

The article points to the financing of Carlyle's investment in healthcare technology firm Cotiviti in early 2023, in which Apollo and Blackstone's credit arms were among the lenders in a $5.5 billion loan. The author describes it as the largest PD transaction ever and notes it was slightly larger than the $5 billion Blackstone facility that supported the take-private of Zendesk by Hellman & Friedman and Permira the year before. The article also observes that club deals, which drew criticism after the global financial crisis over collusion allegations, have returned under a different structure.

The author argues that participating across the capital structure gives managers access to confidential information without the restrictions that apply to public-market insider trading. The article notes that no regulation prevents a sponsor from trading the bonds of a portfolio company ahead of price-sensitive disclosures, and cites Blackstone's incremental disposal of its Hilton stake between 2013 and 2018 as an example of trading while holding private information. It also highlights academic research on conflicts when PE firms invest equity in buyouts while managing CLO funds.

The article contends that private debt offers managers a floor on returns. With corporate valuations near all-time highs, the author says traditional 20% IRR targets for buyouts are no longer attainable, and credit arms offer high single-digit returns with more predictable fees and loan margins than carried interest. Multiple relationships with portfolio companies can also generate fees from restructurings, amendments, and corporate events.

On transparency, the article cites rating agencies noting that private credit lenders need not mark loans to market as banks must, and that borrowers may defer interest and principal. It notes that it is unclear how many portfolio companies borrow from the credit arms of their PE owners, and that KKR Credit does not publicly disclose what share of its loans go to peers' portfolio companies. The author cites the Fortress-TPG Vice Media dispute as an example of lender-sponsor conflict, while stating that collaboration is more likely than open conflict.

The article warns that PE owners often seek to acquire portfolio companies' debt during prolonged market stress, and that sponsor-backed borrowers reportedly violate covenants more often than comparable non-PE borrowers. It draws a historical parallel to J.P. Morgan's concentrated influence over corporations in the Gilded and Progressive eras, and concludes that regulators and stakeholders should monitor the integration of PE and PD to ensure a balanced financial ecosystem.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

1 outlet

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

Cfainstitute Private Equity and Private Debt: Two Sides of the Same Coin