Key Takeaways
- • Goldman Sachs Exchanges interview with Howard Marks (Oaktree Capital Management), Michael Arougheti (Ares Management) and Amanda Lynam (Goldman Sachs Research) addresses surging redemption requests and defaults roiling private credit.
- • Howard Marks estimates the direct lending market approaches $2 trillion, growing rapidly after banks retrenched following the global financial crisis.
- • Amanda Lynam estimates the retail non-traded BDC universe is around 15% of traditional private credit AUM, per PitchBook LCD estimates, with institutional drawdown funds holding the vast majority of assets.
- • Michael Arougheti says non-traded BDCs represent less than 10% of the market and that roughly $5 billion of loan sales per quarter would be needed if all non-traded BDCs hit maximum 5% quarterly redemptions, versus about $85 billion of loans trading quarterly in the syndicated loan market.
- • The 5% quarterly redemption limits are structural features, not gates, according to Lynam and Arougheti, designed to protect illiquid portfolios from forced sales at depressed prices.
Summary
Marks traced the asset class's rise to the aftermath of the global financial crisis, when banks lost capital and faced tighter regulation that limited their lending for leveraged transactions. Private lenders filled the gap, initially commanding high interest rates and strong protections. As capital flooded into the space, those terms eroded. Strong private equity demand for leverage sustained growth, and Marks estimated the direct lending market now approaches $2 trillion. He compared the expansion to a gold rush, noting that heightened competition and risky behavior accompany such upsurges.
Lynam described private credit as one part of a financing continuum alongside bank lending and public debt markets. She said the borrower base has expanded since the financial crisis and especially after the pandemic to include companies able to access public markets that choose private financing for speed, certainty and customization.
On redemptions, Lynam said non-traded or evergreen BDCs, which offer retail investors lower minimums, simpler tax reporting and quick entry, represent about 15% of traditional private credit AUM according to PitchBook LCD, and a much smaller share once broader private credit is included. She stressed that most assets sit in institutional drawdown funds with locked-up capital. She characterized the 5% quarterly redemption limits as a feature that protects illiquid investments from forced liquidation.
Arougheti rejected the term gate, arguing that the structures were designed to provide a path to liquidity of 5% per quarter and 20% per year, with the annual figure tied to the weighted average life of underlying loans. He said portfolios typically hold 20% to 30% in liquid securities, and that non-traded BDCs represent less than 10% of the market. He estimated that meeting maximum redemptions across the non-traded BDC segment would require about $5 billion of quarterly loan sales, a small fraction of the roughly $85 billion of loans trading each quarter in the syndicated loan market, and concluded there is no asset-liability mismatch or run risk.
Marks agreed that limited liquidity is inherent in these vehicles, noting it is absolutely true that the features were designed that way, while questioning retail investors' expectations of liquidity.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.