Key Takeaways
- • Blue Owl Capital's decision to let investors redeem only a set amount each quarter, rather than a fixed sum, triggered a sharp sell-off on Thursday in private credit lenders including Apollo, Ares and Blackstone.
- • Blue Owl disclosed it sold $1.4 billion of loans from three funds with virtually no loss, nearly half of proceeds going to redeem investors in one fund, which analyst Bill Katz of TD Cowen said showed "no 'cockroaches' lurking in the portfolio."
- • Mohamed El-Erian used the "canary in the coal mine" metaphor, while Dan Rasmussen of Verdad told CNBC "the private markets bubble is finally starting to burst."
- • Concern centers on "semi-liquid" vehicles sold to U.S. retail investors that can gate withdrawals, and on heavy private-lender exposure to enterprise software companies facing AI-driven disruption.
- • Sen. Elizabeth Warren urged the Trump administration to demand more disclosures and stress tests for private lenders.
Summary
Shares of private credit lenders were hit hard on Thursday after Blue Owl Capital changed how investors in one of its most prominent funds can withdraw, or redeem, their money. According to the New York Times, the stocks of Apollo, Ares and Blackstone were also shellacked, with Blue Owl the hardest hit. Blue Owl said it would decide how much investors can take back each quarter rather than honoring a set redemption amount. Shares remained under pressure and were down again in premarket trading on Friday.
The move has revived concern about the sector, which has grown rapidly in recent years and is lightly regulated. Skeptics warn that losses could emerge in a downturn if lenders overextended themselves with weak loans, and Jamie Dimon of JPMorgan Chase warned last fall of potential "cockroaches" coming to light. Private credit investors have also worried about stock declines at enterprise software companies, to which private lenders are heavily exposed, as artificial intelligence disrupts that sector. The Times noted that Blue Owl had lent aggressively to these software companies.
Defenders point to Blue Owl's disclosure that it sold $1.4 billion of loans from three funds with virtually no loss, with nearly half of the proceeds used to redeem investors in one fund. Craig Packer, a Blue Owl co-president, told the Times he was receiving congratulations from across the industry. TD Cowen analyst Bill Katz wrote in a research note that the transaction suggested there were no cockroaches in the portfolio. Still, the Times framed the episode against warnings from Mohamed El-Erian, former Pimco chief executive, who used the canary metaphor, and Dan Rasmussen of Verdad, who said the private markets bubble was beginning to burst.
The article also highlighted a policy dimension. The Trump administration has introduced rules making it easier for individual investors to access private equity and private credit, while Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has pushed to deregulate banks. Senator Elizabeth Warren, Democrat of Massachusetts, urged the administration to demand more disclosures and stress tests for private lenders, particularly given retail investors' exposure through vehicles like Blue Owl's fund. The Times noted that Democratic gains in the midterm elections could bring more scrutiny to the sector.
The move has revived concern about the sector, which has grown rapidly in recent years and is lightly regulated. Skeptics warn that losses could emerge in a downturn if lenders overextended themselves with weak loans, and Jamie Dimon of JPMorgan Chase warned last fall of potential "cockroaches" coming to light. Private credit investors have also worried about stock declines at enterprise software companies, to which private lenders are heavily exposed, as artificial intelligence disrupts that sector. The Times noted that Blue Owl had lent aggressively to these software companies.
Defenders point to Blue Owl's disclosure that it sold $1.4 billion of loans from three funds with virtually no loss, with nearly half of the proceeds used to redeem investors in one fund. Craig Packer, a Blue Owl co-president, told the Times he was receiving congratulations from across the industry. TD Cowen analyst Bill Katz wrote in a research note that the transaction suggested there were no cockroaches in the portfolio. Still, the Times framed the episode against warnings from Mohamed El-Erian, former Pimco chief executive, who used the canary metaphor, and Dan Rasmussen of Verdad, who said the private markets bubble was beginning to burst.
The article also highlighted a policy dimension. The Trump administration has introduced rules making it easier for individual investors to access private equity and private credit, while Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has pushed to deregulate banks. Senator Elizabeth Warren, Democrat of Massachusetts, urged the administration to demand more disclosures and stress tests for private lenders, particularly given retail investors' exposure through vehicles like Blue Owl's fund. The Times noted that Democratic gains in the midterm elections could bring more scrutiny to the sector.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.