Key Takeaways
- • The Mets initially faced intense pressure to fire manager Carlos Mendoza following a dramatic mid-season collapse, with the team falling from a half-game lead on August 2 to 1-8 over eight games, dropping to 64-56 and clinging to a one-game Wild Card lead over Cincinnati.
- • Despite widespread speculation and media debate about Mendoza's job security, Steve Cohen and GM David Stearns ultimately decided to retain Mendoza, with no formal discussions occurring between ownership and management about his dismissal.
- • Mendoza received direct text message support from owner Steve Cohen during the period of organizational uncertainty, suggesting Cohen's confidence in the manager despite on-field performance deterioration.
- • The Mets' second-half record of 9-14 and August record of 2-9, including a catastrophic collapse against Atlanta (blowing a 6-0 lead in the fourth inning), fueled speculation that Cohen—known for aggressive roster and managerial changes—would make a managerial change.
- • If the Mets had terminated Mendoza, speculation centered on pursuing Boston Red Sox manager Álex Cora, a former Mets infielder, though Cora's availability remains uncertain given Boston's playoff positioning and his three-year, $22 million extension signed in June.
Summary
The New York Mets faced a critical juncture in late August 2026 as their season collapsed dramatically, triggering widespread debate about manager Carlos Mendoza's future. The team's performance deteriorated sharply in the second half, compiling a 9-14 record and posting a 2-9 August mark that erased a competitive position in the National League Wild Card race. Most strikingly, the Mets held a half-game lead on August 2 before spiraling into a 1-8 stretch with four one-score losses, dropping their overall record to 64-56 and narrowing their Wild Card cushion to a single game over the Cincinnati Reds.
The most vivid symbol of the collapse came in a decisive 11-6 loss to the Atlanta Braves, where the Mets surrendered a 6-0 lead and allowed nine runs in the fourth inning. Combined with the team falling five games behind the Philadelphia Phillies in the NL East, the organizational crisis created immediate pressure on ownership. Steve Cohen, the Mets' owner with a documented history of making aggressive personnel decisions, faced mounting questions about whether he would make a managerial change.
However, despite extensive speculation and debate among analysts and media figures about Mendoza's termination, Cohen and GM David Stearns ultimately elected to retain the manager. According to reports, Stearns and Cohen engaged in no serious conversations about firing Mendoza, effectively closing the chapter on that possibility. Notably, Mendoza disclosed that he had exchanged supportive text messages with Cohen, indicating that ownership provided reassurance to the manager during the turbulent period rather than contemplating his removal.
The decision to retain Mendoza contrasted sharply with some commentary suggesting that termination would have been justified given the magnitude of the mid-season collapse. Had Cohen pursued a managerial change, speculation centered on recruiting Álex Cora of the Boston Red Sox, a former Mets infielder whose availability remained uncertain. Cora's position appeared relatively secure with Boston holding the AL's second Wild Card seed at 66-56 and operating within 4.5 games of the Toronto Blue Jays in the AL East, and the Red Sox front office had recently secured his commitment through a three-year extension worth approximately $22 million.
The most vivid symbol of the collapse came in a decisive 11-6 loss to the Atlanta Braves, where the Mets surrendered a 6-0 lead and allowed nine runs in the fourth inning. Combined with the team falling five games behind the Philadelphia Phillies in the NL East, the organizational crisis created immediate pressure on ownership. Steve Cohen, the Mets' owner with a documented history of making aggressive personnel decisions, faced mounting questions about whether he would make a managerial change.
However, despite extensive speculation and debate among analysts and media figures about Mendoza's termination, Cohen and GM David Stearns ultimately elected to retain the manager. According to reports, Stearns and Cohen engaged in no serious conversations about firing Mendoza, effectively closing the chapter on that possibility. Notably, Mendoza disclosed that he had exchanged supportive text messages with Cohen, indicating that ownership provided reassurance to the manager during the turbulent period rather than contemplating his removal.
The decision to retain Mendoza contrasted sharply with some commentary suggesting that termination would have been justified given the magnitude of the mid-season collapse. Had Cohen pursued a managerial change, speculation centered on recruiting Álex Cora of the Boston Red Sox, a former Mets infielder whose availability remained uncertain. Cora's position appeared relatively secure with Boston holding the AL's second Wild Card seed at 66-56 and operating within 4.5 games of the Toronto Blue Jays in the AL East, and the Red Sox front office had recently secured his commitment through a three-year extension worth approximately $22 million.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.