Key Takeaways
- • Franklin Circuit Judge Thomas Wingate will issue a decision within two weeks on whether to approve a proposed $227.5 million settlement between Kentucky's public pension systems and major hedge fund firms including KKR & Co., Prisma Capital Partners, The Blackstone Group, and Pacific Alternative Asset Management.
- • State employees opposing the settlement argue the $227.5 million recovery is insufficient compensation for alleged breaches of fiduciary duty and excessive hedge fund fees, and contend the settlement would extinguish their ability to continue pursuing claims on behalf of the pension systems.
- • The three state pension system boards have unanimously approved the settlement, with the Kentucky Attorney General's office arguing that settlement benefits exceed litigation risks and that state law designates the attorney general as the pension systems' legal representative.
- • The original case, filed in late 2017 by eight state pensioners, alleged that Kentucky Retirement Systems (now the Kentucky Public Pensions Authority) gambled $1.2 billion on secretive, high-risk hedge fund investments that resulted in significant losses.
- • The dispute centers on whether the settlement adequately compensates pension funds and whether it should be permitted to resolve claims that state employees contend remain viable and unresolved.
Summary
Franklin Circuit Judge Thomas Wingate heard oral arguments on March 26, 2025, regarding approval of a $227.5 million settlement proposed by Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman to resolve a seven-year litigation challenging hedge fund investments made by Kentucky's public pension systems. The judge indicated he would deliver his ruling within two weeks, characterizing the hearing as "very informative."
The settlement faces opposition from a group of state employees represented by attorney Michelle Ciccarelli Lerach, who argue the proposed amount falls far short of compensating the pension funds for alleged breaches of fiduciary duty by hedge fund managers and excessive fee structures. Lerach contended that approving the settlement would "extinguish" her clients' ability to continue pressing claims on behalf of the pension systems, framing the dispute as a violation of due process rights. "They are trying to wipe us out," Lerach told the court.
The state attorney general's office, represented by Justin Clark, head of the civil division, countered that the settlement's benefits substantially outweigh the risks of continued litigation. Clark emphasized that all three state pension system boards have unanimously approved the proposed settlement and stressed that Kentucky state law assigns the attorney general responsibility for representing the pension systems in such matters.
The underlying case originated in late 2017 when eight state pensioners sued several defendants, including former officials of Kentucky Retirement Systems (now the Kentucky Public Pensions Authority) and hedge fund firms KKR & Co., Prisma Capital Partners, The Blackstone Group, and Pacific Alternative Asset Management. The plaintiffs alleged that the pension systems invested approximately $1.2 billion in secretive, high-risk hedge fund vehicles that ultimately resulted in substantial losses for retirees and active members.
The core dispute hinges on whether $227.5 million represents adequate recovery for pensioners and whether state employees should retain the right to pursue additional claims despite the proposed settlement. Judge Wingate's decision will likely determine the path forward for pension system recovery efforts and set precedent regarding settlement approval in complex fiduciary duty cases involving public retirement funds.
The settlement faces opposition from a group of state employees represented by attorney Michelle Ciccarelli Lerach, who argue the proposed amount falls far short of compensating the pension funds for alleged breaches of fiduciary duty by hedge fund managers and excessive fee structures. Lerach contended that approving the settlement would "extinguish" her clients' ability to continue pressing claims on behalf of the pension systems, framing the dispute as a violation of due process rights. "They are trying to wipe us out," Lerach told the court.
The state attorney general's office, represented by Justin Clark, head of the civil division, countered that the settlement's benefits substantially outweigh the risks of continued litigation. Clark emphasized that all three state pension system boards have unanimously approved the proposed settlement and stressed that Kentucky state law assigns the attorney general responsibility for representing the pension systems in such matters.
The underlying case originated in late 2017 when eight state pensioners sued several defendants, including former officials of Kentucky Retirement Systems (now the Kentucky Public Pensions Authority) and hedge fund firms KKR & Co., Prisma Capital Partners, The Blackstone Group, and Pacific Alternative Asset Management. The plaintiffs alleged that the pension systems invested approximately $1.2 billion in secretive, high-risk hedge fund vehicles that ultimately resulted in substantial losses for retirees and active members.
The core dispute hinges on whether $227.5 million represents adequate recovery for pensioners and whether state employees should retain the right to pursue additional claims despite the proposed settlement. Judge Wingate's decision will likely determine the path forward for pension system recovery efforts and set precedent regarding settlement approval in complex fiduciary duty cases involving public retirement funds.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.