AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

Our Turn | A stronger endowment takes transparency - The News-Gazette

Reported by News-gazette
Nov 17, 2026· 3 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • University of Illinois Foundation's endowment trailed its own benchmark in nine of the last 11 fiscal years, according to a guest commentary by finance professors Jeffrey R. Brown and Mathias Kronlund of the Gies College of Business.
  • • Measured against its benchmark, the endowment would have held about $771 million more on June 30, 2026, had it simply matched the index with the same gifts and payouts.
  • • Over the 10 years through fiscal 2025, the endowment posted the lowest return of the 15 Big Ten public universities with a complete published record, per the authors.
  • • The authors estimate matching the benchmark would have provided roughly $31 million more per year to the university, and they note the endowment again trailed its benchmark by a wide margin in fiscal 2026.
  • • The authors urge the foundation to publish returns by asset class and total investment costs, as Michigan and Ohio State already do.
Summary
A guest commentary in The News-Gazette by University of Illinois finance professors Jeffrey R. Brown and Mathias Kronlund challenges the performance record of the University of Illinois Foundation, which manages the university's endowment. The piece responds to a November 10 column by foundation CEO James Moore, who had defended the endowment's results by citing hindsight and legacy investments.

The authors say their analysis scores the foundation against the benchmark its own board selected in advance, a standard practice in the asset-management industry. Since July 2022, that benchmark has been one that can be replicated through low-cost index funds. Measured on that basis, the endowment trailed in nine of the last 11 fiscal years. The authors estimate that matching the benchmark, with the same gifts and payouts, would have left the endowment about $771 million larger on June 30, 2026, or roughly $31 million more per year for the university.

The authors also compare the foundation with peers in its conference. Over the 10 years through fiscal 2025, they report the endowment had the lowest return among the 15 Big Ten public universities with a complete published record. They say Mr. Moore's claim that more than 60 percent of the shortfall came from legacy investments selected before 2022 changes the timing but not the size of the gap, and that the remaining shortfall falls under the current team. They also note that fiscal 2026 saw the endowment again trail its benchmark by a wide margin, after the legacy writedowns had already occurred. The authors state that the paper was not a verdict on individual leaders and say they sent a draft to foundation leadership before publication, which leadership declined to review.

The commentary poses governance questions, including whether the foundation's structure is the best model, whether its board provides effective oversight, whether its investment policies suit the university system, and whether it is sufficiently accountable to stakeholders. As a first step toward transparency, the authors recommend publishing returns by asset class and total investment costs, practices they note Michigan and Ohio State already follow. The authors also cite record new gifts, pledges and commitments last year and argue donor confidence depends on careful investment of those gifts.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

1 outlet

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

News-gazette Our Turn | A stronger endowment takes transparency - The News-Gazette