AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

Investing Is Not Just About Risk and Return, but Also Value Alignment - Open Magazine

Reported by Openthemagazine
Nov 7, 2026· 2 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • The Bombay Stock Exchange's Saatvik 100 Index and the NSE Nifty500 Ahimsa Index, launched a few months before this interview, give Indian investors the first dedicated benchmarks for values-based investing, screening out businesses tied to animal harm and addictive substances such as tobacco and alcohol.
  • • The Wealth Company Mutual Fund's Ethical Fund, launched in 2024 by the Pantomath Group's asset management arm, applies a two-stage process: a faith-based exclusion screen followed by standard fundamental and quantitative equity analysis.
  • • Exclusions cover companies deriving meaningful revenue from alcohol, tobacco, gambling, animal cruelty, meat processing, leather, and narcotic substances.
  • • Aparna Shanker, Chief Investment Officer – Equity at The Wealth Company, argues that ethical screening does not inherently reduce returns, which she calls one of the most persistent myths in investing.
Summary
In a recent Open Magazine feature, the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) and the National Stock Exchange (NSE) are described as having launched indices built on ethical frameworks rooted in Indian philosophy. BSE's Saatvik 100 Index tracks stocks aligned with 'Sattvik' principles, while the NSE Nifty500 Ahimsa Index tracks companies that follow the principle of Ahimsa. Both are designed to exclude businesses involved in activities harmful to animals or in addictive substances such as tobacco and alcohol.

Aparna Shanker, Chief Investment Officer – Equity at The Wealth Company Mutual Fund, described the indices as a defining moment for ethical investing in India, which she said had previously been viewed as a niche concept with limited benchmarks and few products. According to Shanker, the BSE Saatvik 100 is a more concentrated, large-cap oriented universe, while the NSE Nifty500 Ahimsa Index offers a broader set of more than 300 stocks across market capitalisations.

The Wealth Company, the asset management arm of Pantomath Group, offers The Ethical Fund, which it says was among the first products of its kind when launched in 2024. Shanker said the fund's methodology applies two filters: a faith-based screen that excludes companies deriving meaningful revenue from alcohol, tobacco, gambling, animal cruelty, meat processing, leather, narcotic substances and certain harmful practices, and an investment-quality screen covering governance, balance-sheet strength, cash-flow generation, capital allocation, competitive advantage and growth visibility. The firm describes the faith-based filter as determining the investable universe and investment merit as determining the portfolio.

Shanker said investor interest has been encouraging and that conversations have grown more sophisticated, with investors asking about sustainability of business models and long-term societal impact. She added that some investors not seeking a faith-based product still want to avoid addictive products and animal cruelty. On performance, she rejected the view that ethical investing underperforms, arguing that long-term returns are driven by business quality, earnings growth, governance, capital allocation and valuation discipline rather than by the ethical lens applied to the universe.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

1 outlet

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

Openthemagazine Investing Is Not Just About Risk and Return, but Also Value Alignment - Open Magazine