Key Takeaways
- • The North Yorkshire Pension Fund holds £20.5 million in two international tobacco companies, according to new data the Stray Ferret obtained through a freedom of information request.
- • The fund's exposure is £16.8 million in Philip Morris and £3.7 million in British American Tobacco shares and bonds.
- • The holdings sit alongside the council's own spending of £642,000 in 2025/26 on anti-smoking initiatives, a juxtaposition critics say raises ethical questions.
- • The fund is managed by Border to Coast, which manages more than £55 billion and whose responsible investment policy does not exclude tobacco.
Summary
The fund holds Philip Morris (£16.8 million) and British American Tobacco (£3.7 million in shares plus bonds). The Stray Ferret notes that this is at odds with the council's public health role. The government awarded North Yorkshire Council £642,000 in 2025/26 to expand anti-smoking initiatives, including the Living Well Smokefree service. A council report last year described smoking as the biggest preventable killer in the UK, costing North Yorkshire an estimated £400 million per year in health, social care and other costs.
Alex Crumbie, a researcher at Ethical Consumer, said that investing in a company gives it a vote of approval and that tobacco investment helps the firms' long-term profitability and survival. Crumbie argued the council should review the fund and stop investing in inherently harmful companies, adding that ethical investment can still deliver good returns. The article notes that government guidance permits local authority pension managers to consider environmental, social and governance concerns when making investment decisions.
The fund's assets are managed by Border to Coast, a Leeds-based pension pool managing more than £55 billion for public bodies. Its responsible investment policy does not exclude tobacco. A Border to Coast spokesperson said the firm considers sustainability-related risks that are financially significant, and that it seeks to influence companies through dialogue with management and shareholder voting on issues such as climate transition planning, worker health and safety, and governance. The council referred questions to Border to Coast, saying it was responsible for all investment decisions. Councillor Angus Thompson did not respond to a request for comment, and Councillor Matt Walker declined to comment citing a new conflicts of interest policy. This article is the first in a series on the ethics of North Yorkshire Council's pension investments.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.