Key Takeaways
- • American International College (AIC) withdrew $9 million from its unrestricted endowment in fiscal year 2025, leaving the unrestricted fund at $841,000, down from a $6 million withdrawal the prior year, according to audits cited by MassLive.
- • The school projects $17 million in losses through the fiscal year ending June 2028 and has been forced to use all $8 million of its credit line, per a statement from NECHE and the college.
- • The New England Commission of Higher Education (NECHE) has placed AIC on a "show cause" requirement, meaning the college must justify in January why its accreditation should not be revoked or placed on probation.
- • The $23 million endowment is roughly half permanently restricted, and the college reported $8.7 million in losses in fiscal year 2025 after $1.8 million in losses the prior year.
- • President Nicolle Cestero says net tuition is up $4 million and fall enrollment rose 13%, but enrollment remains well below the 3,629 students recorded in 2013.
Summary
The New England Commission of Higher Education has placed the college under a "show cause" requirement, announced in early October, under which AIC must demonstrate in January why its accreditation should not be revoked or placed on probation. The commission had reviewed the school's finances, accepting financial-challenge reports in March and September 2026. Lawrence Schall, the commission's president, declined to detail why those reports were required. The college's accreditation and federal aid eligibility remain in place for now. Boston College education professor Laura De Veau said probation is the most likely outcome of a show-cause hearing and that repeated endowment draws typically attract accreditor attention.
President Nicolle Cestero, who declined an interview, said in a statement that the college is working to "secure its future," citing a $4 million rise in net tuition and a fundraising campaign seeded with $100,000 pledged by two alumni. The college reported tax-document losses of $8.7 million in fiscal 2025 and $1.8 million the year before. Enrollment rose 13% this fall, to 2,185 in 2026 from 1,815 in 2025, but that follows a low point, and total enrollment fell from 3,629 in 2013 to 2,037 in 2024 per federal data. The college has also sharply raised its acceptance rate, admitting nearly every first-time undergraduate applicant in fall 2024.
Peter Stokes of Huron Consulting Group said small private colleges with endowments under $50 million to $100 million are most vulnerable to enrollment cycles, and that probation is not necessarily fatal. Mayor Domenic J. Sarno said his administration has met with college leadership and that the school has described an 18-month plan. The college has not publicly shared further details on its finances or future plans.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.