AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

The missing half of MENA's venture capital data

Reported by Wamda
Nov 17, 2026· 3 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • Nour ElShaeri, startup and VC journalist and CEO of Investment Analyst AI (IA), argues that MENA venture capital data captures only the investments funds make, not the decisions they decline, leaving half of the record missing.
  • • Based on conversations with more than 15 senior investors across Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Egypt, ElShaeri reports that none could readily answer what their firm passed on in the last 24 months that was later raised elsewhere.
  • • The piece contends that the first layer of deal screening is where investment discipline is most often lost, and that undocumented, instinct-based theses do not scale to several hundred proposals.
  • • ElShaeri argues that AI screening tools have removed the labour-cost excuse for maintaining institutional memory, but that criteria must belong to the fund and partners must retain decision authority.
  • • The author discloses that he runs IA, an AI screening platform for VC funds and accelerators in the region that has processed more than 1,000 pitches and participates in NVIDIA's Inception program.
Summary
An opinion piece by Nour ElShaeri, a startup and venture capital journalist who also serves as CEO of Investment Analyst AI (IA), argues that the regional venture capital data record is incomplete. According to the author, monthly and quarterly funding reports have materially improved visibility into round sizes, active funds and sector allocation across the region over the past five years. However, that data records only what funds subscribe to. It does not capture declined opportunities, subsequent outcomes for rejected companies, divergence between a fund's stated thesis and its actual investments, or disagreements among partners.

ElShaeri draws on his work for Arab News, citing conversations over several months with more than 15 senior investors in Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Egypt. He reports that none could readily answer a basic question: what the firm passed on in the last 24 months that was subsequently raised elsewhere, and what that reveals about its decision-making. He characterises the issue as a weakness in how investment decisions are remembered, examined and improved, rather than as an accusation against any firm.

The article identifies a core problem: investment theses are often not written down in a consistently applicable form. Partners describe their focus areas fluently but differently, and the thesis lives in conversation and instinct. The author argues that instinct is well suited to conviction decisions but poorly suited to first-layer screening of several hundred proposals against one standard, and that it leaves no auditable record. This also affects founders, who may reapply with a materially changed company and be assessed without reference to prior conversations.

ElShaeri argues that the historical excuse for incomplete screening records, the labour cost of consistent review, has weakened because AI screening and analysis tools now reduce that cost. He sets out four requirements for useful tools: criteria that belong to the fund rather than a vendor's definition, layered evaluation that sorts rather than sentences proposals, substantiated analysis with sources attached on demand, and institutional memory of what the house has already seen and rejected. He stresses that none of this requires surrendering judgement to a machine and that a disciplined manual record already represents an improvement. He cautions that machines sort while partners decide, and that a record is valuable only if it is consulted.

The author discloses a conflict of interest: he runs IA, an AI screening and evaluation platform for VC funds and accelerators in the region, which has processed more than 1,000 pitches and participates in NVIDIA's Inception program.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

1 outlet

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

Wamda The missing half of MENA's venture capital data