Key Takeaways
- • All 19 Federal Reserve officials, including the 12 voting FOMC members and 7 rotating regional bank presidents, unanimously supported the September 28 rate hike of 25 basis points, raising the federal funds rate to a range of 3.75%–4%.
- • Most FOMC participants expect another rate increase by year-end, though they emphasized decisions at future meetings will depend on incoming economic data and maintain an "open mind" on the policy path.
- • Recent economic weakness—September job creation of just 29,000 (below forecasts) and upward revisions showing 60,000 fewer jobs in July-August than initially reported—has shifted market expectations, with CME FedWatch odds of an October rate hike falling to 17.2% from 37.6% one week prior.
- • Fed Vice Chair Philip Jefferson and New York Fed President John Williams have signaled since the September decision they are "in no hurry" to raise rates further, a dovish tone reinforced by the weak employment report and persistent inflation challenges.
- • The Fed has failed to achieve its 2% inflation target for more than five years, though the September decision reflected confidence in economic and labor market stability as justifying continued tightening.
Summary
The Federal Reserve's September FOMC meeting minutes, released Wednesday, reveal complete unanimity among all 19 top Fed officials on the decision to raise the benchmark federal funds rate by a quarter point on September 28. The vote among the 12 voting FOMC members was recorded as 12–0, and critically, the seven regional bank presidents who rotate onto the committee but were not voting at that particular meeting also backed the decision, underscoring broad institutional alignment on the need for continued monetary tightening.
In their assessment, FOMC participants cited stability in both the economy and labor market as rationale for the hike while emphasizing the persistent need to bring inflation back to the Fed's 2% target. According to the minutes, "most participants assessed that another increase in the target range for the federal funds rate would likely be appropriate by year end," though officials cautioned they would approach each upcoming meeting with an open mind and remain data-dependent in their decisions.
However, the unanimity on September's decision masks emerging cracks in the hawkish consensus. Both Fed Vice Chair Philip Jefferson and New York Fed President John Williams have indicated since the meeting that they see no urgency to raise rates further—a sentiment that gained credibility when the Labor Department reported Friday that September job creation totaled just 29,000, well below forecasts, with additional downward revisions of 60,000 jobs combined for July and August. The unemployment rate ticked up to 4.2% from 4.1% in August. These data have substantially shifted market expectations; CME Group's FedWatch tool shows the probability of an October rate hike has collapsed to 17.2% from 37.6% just one week earlier. With the Fed having missed its inflation goal for more than five years, the confluence of weak labor data and dovish signals from senior policymakers suggests the rate-hiking cycle may be approaching its end sooner than the June consensus had suggested.
In their assessment, FOMC participants cited stability in both the economy and labor market as rationale for the hike while emphasizing the persistent need to bring inflation back to the Fed's 2% target. According to the minutes, "most participants assessed that another increase in the target range for the federal funds rate would likely be appropriate by year end," though officials cautioned they would approach each upcoming meeting with an open mind and remain data-dependent in their decisions.
However, the unanimity on September's decision masks emerging cracks in the hawkish consensus. Both Fed Vice Chair Philip Jefferson and New York Fed President John Williams have indicated since the meeting that they see no urgency to raise rates further—a sentiment that gained credibility when the Labor Department reported Friday that September job creation totaled just 29,000, well below forecasts, with additional downward revisions of 60,000 jobs combined for July and August. The unemployment rate ticked up to 4.2% from 4.1% in August. These data have substantially shifted market expectations; CME Group's FedWatch tool shows the probability of an October rate hike has collapsed to 17.2% from 37.6% just one week earlier. With the Fed having missed its inflation goal for more than five years, the confluence of weak labor data and dovish signals from senior policymakers suggests the rate-hiking cycle may be approaching its end sooner than the June consensus had suggested.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.