Key Takeaways
- • Wharton professors Amy Huber, Stefan Huber, and Christina Zhu's paper "Buying From the Family: Private Equity-Owned Insurers and Their Affiliated Investments" finds that PE-owned insurers pay higher prices for harder-to-value affiliated securities than other investors buying the same security on the same day.
- • By 2024, structured securities made up more than 40% of PE-owned insurers' new investments, and affiliated businesses issued more than 60% of those structured securities.
- • The authors estimate that under a 2008-style stress scenario, affiliated structured securities could add losses equal to about 4% of PE-owned insurers' fixed-income portfolios, more than half of their 7.6% equity buffer in 2024.
- • PE-owned insurers are less willing to impair or sell affiliated investments when arm's-length valuations fall below cost, and these securities subsequently underperform.
- • The authors recommend that regulators monitor insurers' affiliated exposures, transaction prices, and valuations, and that investors alongside affiliated insurers conduct their own price and risk analysis.
Summary
The authors frame the rapid growth of private credit as a puzzle, since private funds carry a high cost of capital, with limited partners typically requiring an 8% return before general partners earn carried interest, while credit returns depend largely on spread. Integration with insurers, which hold long-duration, stable liabilities, may offer a cheaper and more stable funding source and reduce information frictions. However, the authors note that integration may weaken the arm's-length discipline governing insurer investments.
The scale of affiliated investment is central to the findings. By 2024, structured securities accounted for more than 40% of PE-owned insurers' new investments, and affiliated businesses issued more than 60% of those. The authors argue that information advantages alone do not explain the results: PE-owned insurers pay higher prices than other buyers of the same security on the same day, and are less willing to impair or sell when arm's-length valuations fall below cost, yet these securities subsequently underperform. In their words, "a business originating an investment can also influence a large, long-term buyer of that investment."
Using stress-loss projections produced by insurance regulators, because a repeat of the 2008-09 financial crisis was not observable in their sample period, the authors find that CLO securities held more heavily by affiliated PE-owned insurers show substantially larger losses. Applying this to affiliated structured securities implies an additional loss of about 4% of PE-owned insurers' fixed-income portfolios, more than half their 7.6% equity buffer in 2024. The authors caution that this is an estimate requiring several assumptions.
The authors recommend that regulators examine the relationship between insurers and the entities originating their investments, not only the securities themselves, and monitor affiliated exposures, transaction prices, and subsequent valuations. For practitioners, they advise caution in treating an affiliated insurer's participation as a vote of confidence, noting that such insurers may have different incentives and that co-investors need their own view of price and risk. They also flag the need for future research on the financing chain linking asset-backed finance and private credit, including applications to AI infrastructure.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.