AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

Why Are So Many Quality Funds Falling Behind?

Reported by Morningstar
Nov 16, 2026· 3 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • Morningstar reports that the 10 mutual funds and ETFs with the highest share of wide-moat stocks were up an average of 6% year to date through September 2026, versus 14% for funds with the lowest share of wide-moat holdings.
  • • Vanguard Dividend Growth (VDIGX) gained a cumulative 40% over five years through September 2026, versus over 81% for the Morningstar US Total Stock Market Index; subadvisor Wellington replaced its managers and changed strategy in July 2026.
  • • Jensen Quality Growth (JENSX) assets have fallen to one-third of 2021 levels after poor performance, and the firm cut staff by 28%; Champlain Small Company (CIPSX) assets dropped to $3.8 billion from $22 billion in 2021.
  • • Morningstar lowered its People and Process ratings on Vanguard Dividend Growth and its Parent and People ratings on Jensen, and lowered Champlain's Parent rating to Average, citing manager changes and staff departures.
  • • Morningstar's analysts suggest passive quality exposure such as Vanguard Dividend Appreciation Index (Gold-rated) may be the stronger choice, while noting that quality funds historically outperform in bear markets.
Summary
Quality-oriented funds have underperformed sharply in 2026, according to Morningstar FundInvestor's October 2026 issue. The 10 mutual funds and ETFs with the highest percentage of wide-moat stocks were up an average of just 6% year to date through September 2026, compared with 14% for funds holding the fewest wide-moat stocks. Morningstar describes the stretch as unusually tough for funds that emphasize quality.

Vanguard Dividend Growth (VDIGX) illustrates the problem. Over five years through September 2026 it gained a cumulative 40%, while the Morningstar US Total Stock Market Index gained more than 81%. Subadvisor Wellington Asset Management changed the fund's manager and strategy in July 2026, naming Tim Casaletto and Tom Levering to replace Peter Fisher, who had succeeded Don Kilbride in 2024. The new managers are more willing to own cyclical firms and are relaxing the requirement that holdings pay and increase dividends. Morningstar lowered its People and Process ratings to Average.

Drivers cited by Morningstar include dividends, valuations, and AI-related software disruption. Many of the fastest-growing market leaders pay no dividend or very small ones. Winning tech companies trade at stretched valuations, and investors have favored high revenue growth over steady cash flow. Fears that AI agents would let software users write their own code, reducing licensing fees, weighed on software stocks and quality funds this year, and hedge funds reportedly shorted software while buying AI names. Software has rebounded recently but remains weak for the year. Harbor Capital Appreciation (HACAX), which holds wide-moat AI-linked names such as Nvidia, Apple and CrowdStrike, has performed well.

Active funds have also suffered outflows. Jensen Quality Growth (JENSX) trailed Vanguard Dividend Growth by 9 percentage points over five years, with holdings such as Sherwin-Williams, Marsh and Mastercard weighing on results. The firm now manages one-third of the assets it held in 2021 and cut staff by 28%. Morningstar downgraded its Parent and People ratings to Average. Champlain Small Company (CIPSX) returned 9.5% cumulatively over five years (1.8% annualized), 21 percentage points behind Jensen. Its assets fell to $3.8 billion from $22 billion in 2021. Co-CIO Corey Bronner and analyst Andrew Hanson departed at the end of 2025 without replacement, and Morningstar lowered its Parent rating to Average.

Passive quality has fared better. Vanguard Dividend Appreciation Index (VDADX) was 14 percentage points behind the total market over five years, but its 66% cumulative gain placed it in the third quartile. Morningstar holds a Gold rating on it, compared with Bronze for Vanguard Dividend Growth and Neutral for the Champlain and Jensen funds. Morningstar notes that in past deep-value recoveries, the most punished funds rebounded most strongly, but also says quality typically holds up better in bear markets, and that a prolonged software-driven margin squeeze could extend the slump.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

1 outlet

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

Morningstar Why Are So Many Quality Funds Falling Behind?