Key Takeaways
- • CalPERS CEO Marcie Frost, in an Oct. 23 comment letter, urged the SEC to withdraw its Sept. 16 proposal to rescind Rule 14a-8, warning that a "patchwork" of state laws would force investors to track potentially all 50 state legal regimes.
- • The Council of Institutional Investors, representing more than 135 U.S.-based pension funds, filed a 43-page Nov. 5 comment letter opposing rescission on the grounds that it would shift costs to investors.
- • Business groups, including the National Association of Manufacturers and the American Securities Administration, support the rescission, arguing the shareholder proposal process has been "hijacked" by special interest groups.
- • Stakeholders on both sides warn that rescinding the rule could trigger a near-term spike in litigation; the SEC comment period closes Nov. 20 and a final rule could follow next year.
Summary
The central question is who should decide when shareholder proposals reach proxy materials: a single federal standard or a mix of state law and company-specific bylaws. In its proposal, the SEC determined that Rule 14a-8, adopted in 1942, exceeds the agency's statutory authority and intrudes into matters of state law. SEC Chair Paul Atkins has questioned the agency's influence over the shareholder proposal process, and he directed staff to examine the rule's scope and merits following a July speech.
Institutional investors reject that assessment. In an Oct. 23 letter, CalPERS CEO Marcie Frost wrote that abandoning a unified federal standard would introduce "more inefficiency and legal uncertainty into U.S. capital markets," noting that a diversified investor would otherwise need to track the legal regimes of all 50 states and the governing documents of thousands of portfolio companies. Jeff Mahoney, general counsel at the Council of Institutional Investors, said in a 43-page Nov. 5 letter that rescission "would split the process into state-by-state and company-by-company rules and shift costs to investors." Asset owners argue that rescinding the rule would make it harder to pursue change on issues such as board composition, CEO pay and climate risk.
Business interests largely favor the proposal. The National Association of Manufacturers said the process has been "hijacked by a cadre of professional shareholder proponents," and the American Securities Administration, a trade group representing financial services firms, made a similar argument. ASA President and CEO Chris Iacovella said in a statement that the rule had let "a small group of well-funded special interest groups, aided by politically driven funds and proxy advisors" push political agendas onto corporate ballots.
Despite their disagreement, stakeholders on both sides warn that rescinding the rule could lead to a near-term increase in litigation. The SEC will now consider the comments it has received and could issue a final rule next year.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.