Key Takeaways
- • Axonic Insurance (AXI) published a White Paper, "The Growing Opportunity: Meeting the Challenge in the Annuity Market," arguing that alternative asset manager-owned insurers have become firmly established in the fixed and fixed indexed annuity market.
- • Greenwald Research surveyed 301 financial professionals who placed at least four fixed and/or fixed indexed annuities in the past year and interviewed 16 industry observers; 52% rated alternative asset manager-owned insurers stronger product innovators versus 12% for traditional insurers.
- • Forty percent of surveyed professionals expect to increase placements with alternative asset manager-owned insurers over the next two years, versus 3% expecting decreases.
- • Six in ten respondents believe more regulation is "needed" or "probably needed," and 94% review rating-agency ratings at least sometimes.
- • AXI contends ownership structure alone does not measure risk, and proposes six evaluation criteria: asset-liability matching, valuation, affiliated transactions, reinsurance, financial resources, and transparency.
Summary
Among surveyed professionals, 52% said alternative asset manager-owned insurers are stronger product innovators than traditional insurers, while 12% said traditional insurers are better. Forty percent credited these insurers with stronger investment capabilities, compared with 13% who asserted the reverse. Forty percent of knowledgeable professionals expect to increase placements with them over the next two years, against 3% who expect to decrease placements.
The survey also points to the importance of financial strength in product selection. Ninety-four percent of professionals review rating-agency ratings at least sometimes, and 60% are paying more attention to fixed and fixed indexed annuity risk-management practices than five years ago. Six in ten believe more regulation is either "needed" or "probably needed."
AXI's central conclusion, as stated by CEO Michael Gordon, is that "the issue is not the ownership of the insurer." The company argues that risk should be assessed through asset-liability matching, supportable asset valuations, demonstrably arm's-length affiliated transactions, counterparties' ability to perform under stress, adequate resources to support potential reinsurance recapture, and sufficient transparency for regulators, distributors, rating agencies and financial professionals. The paper describes AXI's own practices, including publishing GAAP audited financial statements with a high-level statutory translation, maintaining arm's-length arrangements with its affiliated asset manager, retaining third-party governance expertise, and monitoring portfolios against allocation, quality, affiliate and single-obligor limits.
The release is a company-sponsored communication, and the research was commissioned by Axonic Insurance. The White Paper is available at axonicinsurance.com/insights.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.