AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

‘All the choices we have to make are bad’: Heisler warns about slashing city pension as budget fix

Reported by Triblive
Nov 16, 2026· 3 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • Pittsburgh Mayor Corey O'Connor's proposed $727 million 2027 budget would cut pension funding by $10 million a year over five years, a $50 million reduction in total, while still allocating about $98 million annually to the pension.
  • • Controller Rachael Heisler called the choices facing council "all bad" and warned that deferring pension payments is equivalent to deferred maintenance that "will catch up with you."
  • • The pension is 82% funded and serves about 3,000 active and 4,000 retired employees; employees contribute roughly $17 million a year, a figure not reflected in the budget.
  • • An outside actuarial firm commissioned by the pension board is expected to report before Thanksgiving with options to mitigate the financial impact, with allocating more parking tax revenue to the pension floated as one possibility.
  • • Officials have ruled out another property tax increase for 2027, and alternatives such as a tax on unearned income or a higher Local Services Tax face legal or state-approval hurdles that make them unlikely to help in the current cycle.
Summary
Pittsburgh Controller Rachael Heisler used a Monday council meeting to press members on the most concerning element of Mayor Corey O'Connor's proposed $727 million 2027 budget: a $50 million reduction in pension funding over the next five years, implemented as $10 million less per year. According to the report, the plan still allocates about $98 million to the pension annually. Heisler argued that deferring pension payments is comparable to skipping bridge maintenance, pointing to the 2022 collapse of the Fern Hollow Bridge in Frick Park after years of deferred upkeep.

O'Connor inherited a fiscal crisis that many officials believe his predecessor understated. The proposal includes no tax increase and no layoffs, but it eliminates vacant positions and cuts additional funding for the Housing Opportunity and Stop the Violence funds. Heisler acknowledged there is no painless path to a workable budget, saying "All the choices we have to make are bad," and describing options such as reducing pension funding as "crappy decisions." She warned that cuts, even short-lived ones, can compound and that the practice could persist longer than anticipated. The pension is 82% funded and serves roughly 3,000 active and 4,000 retired employees. Heisler also noted that employees contribute about $17 million a year, a figure not reflected in the budget. Officials do not yet have estimates of the long-term effects of the proposed cuts.

Heisler said an outside actuarial firm, engaged at the pension board's request, expects to finish its analysis before Thanksgiving and will offer council options to "mitigate a lot of the financial impacts." She did not specify those options but suggested that directing more parking tax revenue to the pension in future years could be part of the strategy. Councilman Bob Charland, D-South Side, warned that reduced maintenance spending now will generate higher costs later, noting that his proposal to hire two industrial painters for bridges and infrastructure would not be feasible under the mayor's plan.

Council members also raised concerns about depleting the reserve fund, the difficulty of trimming an already lean budget, and the burden of another tax hike after property taxes rose 20% to balance the current year's budget. Deputy Controller Peter McDevitt, council's former budget director, said that cutting alone would require closing every recreation center and pool, and that eliminating the entire Parks and Recreation budget would still not close the gap. Officials have said they do not want to raise property taxes again. Councilwoman Barb Warwick, D-Greenfield, has proposed a tax on unearned income such as dividends and capital gains, but it would take time to implement and would likely face significant legal opposition. Some leaders have called for raising the Local Services Tax, currently $52 a year, which would require state legislative approval. McDevitt cautioned that the problem cannot be solved within the four weeks council has to pass the budget.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

1 outlet

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

Triblive ‘All the choices we have to make are bad’: Heisler warns about slashing city pension as budget fix